The Purcell principle explained: why the Supreme Court let New Hampshire limit student IDs
Standfirst: The unsigned order turned on timing rather than on whether the law is fair. Here is the legal doctrine behind it, the dispute over how it was used, and what it means for student voters.
When the US Supreme Court allowed New Hampshire to keep student ID cards out of its polling places on Thursday, 22 October 2026, it did not rule on whether the state’s law is valid. It relied on a doctrine called the Purcell principle, which tells federal courts to avoid changing election rules close to an election. Understanding that doctrine explains both the decision and the dissent.
Four facts at a glance
The Court ruled on timing, not on whether the law is valid.
The order is unsigned and one paragraph long. Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson dissented.
The state law, House Bill ...