Meta $25 Billion Fine: New Mexico Judge Orders Largest Penalty Against Facebook’s Owner

The Meta $25 billion fine is the largest ever imposed on the owner of Facebook. On Wednesday, a New Mexico judge ordered the company to pay the state that amount after a jury found it had deceived users about privacy and content moderation. Judge Francis Mathew of the First Judicial District Court in Santa Fe issued the order more than three weeks after the jury’s verdict. Meta told ABC News it will appeal.

The case grew out of the Cambridge Analytica scandal. In that episode, the political consulting firm harvested Facebook user data to build targeted political ads for the 2016 U.S. election. Jurors found in September that Meta had committed more than 43 million violations of New Mexico’s consumer protection laws. New Mexico Attorney General Raúl Torrez called the judgment the largest single-state verdict against the company in American history and said it should serve as a warning to the technology industry.

How the Meta $25 billion fine was set

The number came out of a wide gap between the two sides. The state had asked the judge for a penalty of $35 billion to $45 billion, according to ABC News, though other outlets reported the lower end of that request as $35 billion to $40 billion. Meta’s lawyers argued the total should not exceed about $3.4 billion, and one of its attorneys said a figure as high as $40 billion would shock the conscience. The judge landed far closer to the state’s position than to the company’s.

According to a report from NTD, the judge found that New Mexico law would have supported a penalty of more than $219 billion, and he reduced it to $25 billion. HCN has seen that detail in only one outlet, so it should be checked against the court order before it is relied on. In his written ruling, the judge said Facebook’s conduct was intentional and that its executives repeatedly misled users about how the platform worked. Meta has argued that the state failed to prove any misleading statements about privacy.

Why the Meta $25 billion fine stands out

The penalty dwarfs the $5 billion that the Federal Trade Commission imposed on Facebook in 2019 over its privacy practices. It is also notable that New Mexico took this case to trial alone. Reports say Meta reached a large multistate settlement in August with nearly all other states. Outlets differ on its size, with figures of $17.1 billion and $18 billion, and on exactly which claims it covered, so HCN does not treat that comparison as exact.

For scale, Meta has said it had about $201 billion in sales last year. By HCN’s arithmetic, $25 billion is roughly 12 per cent of that figure, although a fine is not the same thing as a year’s profit. Meta’s lawyers had warned the court that a penalty far above their proposal would be extreme. New Mexico’s lawyers argued that only a sum large enough to affect the company’s stock price would change its behavior.

Who is affected

Under the New Mexico Constitution, fines for consumer protection violations go toward state education spending, and the attorney general said the money will be directed to an education fund. None of the reports HCN reviewed said that individual Facebook users will receive payments. For users, the immediate effect is therefore indirect: it is a legal finding that the company misled people about their data, plus a financial penalty that benefits the state’s schools if it survives appeal.

Readers should also not confuse this case with a separate New Mexico lawsuit. In March, a different jury ordered Meta to pay $375 million over claims that it misled users about child safety on its platforms. That case moved to a later phase before a judge, and HCN did not find its outcome in the sources reviewed for this story.

What happens next

Meta has said it will appeal, and interest on the penalty would accrue while the appeal is pending, according to AP. Appeals courts can reduce or overturn large penalties, so the amount is not final. The company is expected to challenge both the findings and the size of the judgment. For more coverage of technology and accountability, visit the Human Crisis News homepage, and read the AP’s full report on the ruling for more detail.

Stay informed. Stay human.

Get the latest global crisis updates, breaking news, and in-depth reports delivered directly to your inbox.

No spam. Unsubscribe anytime. Your privacy is respected.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Toggle Dark Mode